de | cn | ru
  VS.    

QUOINEX

QUOINEX Review
Trader's rating 1
Editor's rating 3.8

Trading accounts

 

Account type Minimum deposit Leverage Fees
Standard Undisclosed 1: 25 0.25%*

*While the company claims to offer 0% fees for Japanese clients, the situation is not that clear for the rest. Go to the fees section of the review for more details.

QUOINEX (which stands for QUOINE Exchange) is a relatively new competitor in the cryptocurrency space. The company behind this project operates two brands – one focused on accepting fiat currency deposits (this one) and another one for digital asset trading (QRYPTOS). This is similar to the business model used by Coinbase/GDAX and OKCoin/OKEX.



The company, security of funds

Company Country Regulation
QUOINE Pte. Ltd Japan/Singapore/Vietnam JFSA

 

QUOINE Pte. Ltd is the company behind QUOINEX. They operate from offices in Japan, Singapore and Vietnam, but more importantly they recently got the regulatory approval of the JFSA. This brings a lot of credibility to the exchange, as regulated entities are few in the crypto-space.



QUOINE was founded in 2014 and later received substantial funding. The company’s founders Mike Kayamori and Mario Gomez-Lozada have substantial experience in the “traditional” business world, which also makes the project sound better.



While there weren’t any major hacks at QUOINEX, we must mention the most famous case of a conflict with a client. The cryptocurrency market-maker B2C2 is currently suing the company after a canceled a major transaction. Reports state, B2C2 made around $3.7 million on a trade/s, which was/were allegedly executed at a price which was very distant from the current market price. QUOINEX claimed this was an abuse of a technical issue, and reverted the deals. We can’t clearly state which side of the argument is right, but we must mention this incident occurred before the company was regulated by the Japanese financial watchdog.



There aren’t many English reviews on QUOINEX, but a lot of them are fairly negative. The complaints are mostly on slow withdrawal process and high fees on deposits (which are not charged by the company, but by the partnering banks). 



Trading conditions


 
Trading instruments (cryptocurrencies)
The cryptocurrencies available at QUOINEX are only Bitcoin and Ethereum, while more altcoins are available at QRYPTOS. More importantly, trading can be done against a lot of fiat currencies: USD, JPY, EUR, AUD, SGD, HKD, IDR and PHP. On top of that there are three types of trading: spot (without leverage), margin and futures. The latter can be quite tricky, so we don’t recommend it to beginners.


 
Minimum initial deposit
There is no information on the minimum deposit requirement at QUOINEX. This is not usually the case with the forex brokers, which we mostly cover. As an example FXCM requires $50 for the creation of a new account.


 
Leverage
QUOINEX offers leverage up to 1:25. This is one of the highest levels available for cryptocurrency trading, which should be used wisely. As you may know forex brokers usually offer even higher ratios, like 1:500. This is due to the fact traditional currencies are much less volatile than Bitcoin.

 

Be sure to fully understand the ways margin trading operates before participating in it. One must also be aware of the differences between trading Bitcoin with a forex broker and an exchange, one of which is the margin fee, applied by some exchanges. In the case of QUOINEX, the fee is set at 5%.


 
Fees
There are no fees on trading with your “base currency pair” at QUOINEX. When trading with against other currencies the fees go as high as 0.25% which is in line with the industry standards.



Your account’s “base currency pair” will be determined on your country of residence. All of the examples given at the website, state you will trade with zero fees, if you are based in Japan. That being the case, there isn’t total clarity on the fees, if you are not a Japanese client. Here is a screenshot of their fee structure (zoom-in to see the explanation in the bottom):




 
 

Trading platform


 
QUOINEX provides a web-based trading solution. They are one of the few companies, which offers a demo account. Here is what you get, after registering one:





The charting seems very solid and reminiscent of the package provided by bitFlyer. On the left side of the chart, we can see a nice order entry panel followed by the order book and tape. The latter two are surprisingly placed above one another. This is very counter-intuitive to seasoned traders.


 
Methods of payment


 
QUOINEX accepts bank transfers in multiple currencies. We must note, the processing times for the more exotic ones are fairly longer. Additionally, transfers in Bitcoin or Ethereum are also accepted. The lack of credit card or e-wallet (servies like PayPal or Netteler) support will tun away some potential new clients.


 
Conclusion


 
QUOINEX is a cryptocurreny exchange, which is regulated by the JFSA. The company accepts Bank Transfers, which makes it a competitor in the “entry service provider” category. Commissions are competitive, despite a lack of clarity on the “0% fees” for non-Japanese clients. The trading platform feels solid, although the positioning of the order books and tape is a bit odd. Here are the pros and cons of QUOINEX:

 

Pros Cons
JFSA Regulation No altcoins available (ex. ETH)
No major hacks yet Some negative user reviews
Accepts Bank Transfers Odd positioning of some elements of the trading platform
Competitive commissions  
Relatively nice trading platform   
Allows margin trading and futures     


 

KorBit

KorBit Review
Trader's rating 1
Editor's rating 3.8

Trading Accounts

 

Account type Leverage Maker Fee Taker fee Deposit Fee
Standard N/A Max 0.08% Max 0.20% Free

 

KorBit was the first Korean cryptocurrency exchange to offer BTC/KRW trading. They are an entry-level service (i.e. accept fiat currencies) but also offer a decent trading platform. The company is still one of the top-rated exchanges in the country, which drives relatively high trading volumes.

 

KorBit Advantages

 

Competitive fees –   The trading fees at KorBit are divided into the “maker” and “taker” category. Market makers are the traders who place a new entry in the order book, while takers are those who enter at the best available price. The fees at KorBit start from 0.08% and 0.20%, respectively. They can go even lower if you trade with bigger volumes. 

 

Cold storage – KorBit claims a majority of the coins they keep are kept in cold storage. This is a measure, applied by a lot of companies and drastically increases the security of wallets.

 

Several altcoins featured  – There are some alternative coins available at KorBit, but this is by no means the main benefit of the exchange (as is the case with Poloniex or Bittrex). The full list currently includes: Bitcoin, Bitcoin Cash, Ethereum, Ethereum Calassic, Ripple, Litecoin, Dash, Zcash, Monero, Augur and Steem. They are all traded against KWR.

 

KRW bank transfers accepted – Bank transfers from Korean banks are accepted at KorBit. More importantly, the company does not charge fees on any incoming transactions (although the banks involved in the process will). 

 

>> Purchase Bitcoin with a credit card<<

 

Credit cards are a much more preferable option for some users, although the commissions involved in the process can be pretty harsh. As an example Bitsatmp charges 8% on such transactions. 

 

 

Positive user feedback – While the non-Korean reviews of this exchange are relatively few in number, they are all positive. The company seems to operating legitimately, and with the competitive fee structure, most customers should be happy.

 

Nice trading platform – The web-based platform delivered by KorBit looks solid. Charting is provided by TradingView, which is always nice. Additionally the order book and tape (trading history), which are located below the chart also seem well-designed. Her is how they look: 

 

BTC/KRW chart. While the default template is simplistic it can easily be changed via the TradingView package.

 

The easy to read order book and tape.

 

KorBit Disadvantages

 

 

Focus on Korea – The issue, which a lot of locally focused exchanges have is also present at KorBit. They accept only Korean bank transfers and likely require such an account for the verification of your main trading account. The presentation in English, while not terrible is also not ideal.

 

 

Trading against KWR –  All of the trading activity at KorBit is done against the Korean Won (KWR). This may seem nice for local clients, but limits their ability for currency diversification and the option of quickly converting one coin into another.

 

Withdrawal fees – KorBit applies fees on withdrawals. They may not seem significant, but especially the ones imposed on blockchain transfers are annoying. Here is the list which also states all deposits are free of charge:

 

 

No leverage provided  – Margin trading isn’t supported by KorBit, which isn’t that big of a flaw. Cryptocurrencies are so volatile, that most traders don’t have the need to further increase the risks they are exposed to. For those of you who are willing to take even more aggressive steps, we must will recommend trading with as forex broker.

 

>>Leveraged Bitcoin trading brokers<< 

 

That being said, we must also underline the fact this style of trading is not suitable for long term investing. Trading with such brokers is done via the so called CFDs and is very different from going through a crypto-exchange. Read all of the important points here.

 

Conclusion

 

KorBit is one of the oldest cryptocurrency exchanges in Korea. The company has earned a solid reputation and is still very popular. That being said, their main flaw (from our perspective) is the domestic focus of this exchange. While they are not unique in that regard, as other Korean companies, like Coinone and Bithumb also operate in the same manner. 

 

The trading conditions at this exchange are solid – the instrument list features some altcoins, the platform is nice and the fees are up to date with the offers from other exchanges.

 

That being said, when dealing with cryptocurrencies, you must always consider the fact, there will be a certain level of uncertainty. Most veterans in the field would advice you to transfer any larger amounts of coins to a private wallet, whose private keys you control (or even a hardware wallet, like the Trezor or Ledger Nano). With that in mind, the forex brokers, which we mentioned earlier are often much safer alternatives. Click the link below for more details.

 

>>Tightly regulated Bitcoin forex brokers<<

 

And here is the final summary of this exchange (keep in mind, we are viewing it form an outside perspective, as we are not based in Korea):

 

Pros Cons
Competitive Fees Focus on Korea
Cold Storage Trading against KWR
Several altcoins featured Withdrawal fees
KRW bank transfers accepted No leverage provided
No deposit fees  
Positive user feedback  
Nice trading platform   

 

Forex
de | cn | ru