de | cn | ru

Brokers News

FXCM Encourages CFTC to Impose Better Rules for Customer Protection

LeapRate has just reported that FXCM, one of the world’s biggest forex brokers, has sent a letter to the U.S. Commodities Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), strongly encouraging the Commission to implement better rules for customer protection. 

 
It would appear that FXCM has had enough of the panic-caused and hectic actions of the CFTC and the National Futures Associations (NFA) after two major brokers – MF Global and PFG Best – went down this past year, partially because of negligence on behalf of the two regulators. Now both CFTC and NFA are overcompensating with some ridiculous measures – such as bullying FXDD to put aside $3.3 million in case it is found guilty in an investigation on its slippage practice for example. 
 
FXCM’s letter to the CFTC (which I’m pasting below, courtesy on LeapRate), makes some very valid points, and even though the letter doesn’t say it directly, I get the feeling that the broker is accusing the regulatory body of two things: one, a witch hunt against retail foreign exchange dealers (RFEDs) futures commission merchants (FCMs); and two – that the CFTC is not doing enough to protect the customers. 
 
Or perhaps, this is just my own opinion and I’m trying to project it anywhere and everywhere. Either way, I really have the feeling that things must change on the US retail forex scene for the market to pick up – just in the last few months, three major brokers withdrew their licenses and exited that market – Advanced Markets, Forex Club and most recently – GFT
 
 

FXCM's letter to the CFTC

 
December 12, 2012
 
Mr. David Stawick
Secretary
Commodity Futures Trading Commission
1155 21st Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20581
 
Re: Enhancing Protections Afforded Customers and Customer Funds Held by Futures Commission Merchants and Derivatives Clearing Organizations: (RIN3038-AD88)
 
Dear Mr. Stawick:
 
Forex Capital Markets LLC (“FXCM”) is a retail foreign exchange dealer (“RFED”) and Forex Dealer Member of the National Futures Association (“NFA”).  FXCM has been registered with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (“CFTC”) as a Futures Commission Merchant (“FCM”) since 2001 and is one of the leading U.S. firms offering off-exchange forex trading to retail clients around the world.  FXCM is proud of its position as an industry leader in retail FX both in the United States and globally.  FXCM has been a staunch advocate for increased regulation for the U.S. forex industry and the protection of retail forex customers.  FXCM submits these comments in response to the Commission’s November 14, 2012 rulemaking proposal (the “November 14th Proposal”) concerning “Enhancing Protections Afforded Customers and Customer Funds held by Futures Commission Merchants and Derivatives Clearing Organizations.”
 
FXCM believes that in light of the bankruptcies of MF Global and PFG Best the regulations contained in the November 14th Proposal are necessary.  However, we are concerned they do not go far enough in protecting the trading public and would therefore like to propose additional protections.  Since the financial crisis of 2008, many FCMs and RFEDs have been struggling financially as the traditional business model for FCMs and RFEDs has come under enormous pressure.  FCMs earn commissions on each trade their customers make; however, electronic trading has caused a price competition among FCMs that has resulted in falling commissions throughout the industry.  RFEDs earn revenue on the bid/ask spread but tightening spreads in the industry have pressured RFED bottom lines as well.
 
Additionally, interest rates have plummeted depriving FCMs and RFEDs of a large portion of revenue derived from the interest collected on customer deposits.  Furthermore, decreased volatility throughout all financial markets has lowered the amount of trading in general.  This constant pressure on revenues can result in a firm making aggressive, losing bets with client funds (MF Global) or in outright fraud (PFG Best).
 
It is precisely because of this challenging business climate that we believe the following two proposals be given serious consideration.
 
 
Require all FCMs and RFEDs to employ a Top Ten Accounting Firm

One of the many reasons that Russ Wasendorf Sr. was able to get away with his Ponzi scheme for so long was that PFG Best had very poor internal accounting procedures.  While no accounting firm is perfect, there should be much higher accounting standards for FCMs and RFEDs.   The Platt Group publishes an annual ranking of public accounting firms that could be used by FCMs and RFEDs.  Whether it is top 10 or top 25, FCMs and RFEDs should use a nationally recognized and respected accounting firm that will apply the same accounting standards that publicly traded companies must meet.

 

Require All FCMs and RFEDs to Publish a Consolidated Balance Sheet and Income Statement Once a Quarter

Futures Commission Merchants are very unique in the world of finance.  They hold customer funds that are supposed to be in segregated accounts but they have no insurance in the event the firm goes bankrupt.  The entire system revolves around trust.  But with that trust violated something more must be offered to ease the investing public’s mind, specifically, a complete, fully audited, and publicly disclosed consolidated balance sheet and income statement.

Currently, the CFTC publishes monthly “Net Capital” reports that disclose to the public how much money a FCM or RFED has set aside in capital.  However, that report provides very little insight into how well the company is doing financially.  By requiring FCMs and RFEDs to publish a quarterly, consolidated balance sheet and income statement the trading public will know how much risk they are taking with each firm since investors will be able to weigh the liabilities along with the excess capital that a firm has. 

Furthermore, the published balance sheet and income statement should include everything (i.e. holding company’s financials) since what happens to other subsidiaries of the company can easily effect the regulated entity.  Each company should be required to provide a link to these financial statements on its own homepage so that the public can conduct proper due diligence.

Too often, those FCMs and RFEDs that are on the edge of insolvency lure customers in by marketing unsustainable offers (low commissions, account opening bonuses) that temporarily puts off the inevitable.  If traders have access to such a firm’s income statement they will be able to see for themselves that these kinds of marketing gimmicks may not be producing revenue for the firm (or even leading to losses) and this will allow the trader to make a safer choice and also discourage firms from engaging in uneconomical business practices.   One customer found this out the hard way:


“But Khan was not worried about risk or diversification when he moved his money to PFG Best, he said. He had been aggressively saving for years and wanted to venture into commodities, which can produce high returns though with increased risk, to further grow his $380,000 nest egg.

In December, Khan transferred all his money from a Charles Schwab account to PFG Best, attracted by low fees that were half the cost of Schwab's and the faster trading platform.”

Had customers like Khan known the poor state of the finances of firms like PFG (who routinely hard sell these illusory discounts) then such a tragedy could have been avoided. 

In addition, by requiring this additional disclosure customers will be able to watch out for firms who take excessive risks and have abnormally high volatility in their earnings, and other warning signs they may not be aware of.  This would require firms to be more vigilant with the risks they are taking. 

PFG Best highlights the need for putting the public interest ahead of the desire of many FCMs and RFEDs to keep their financials private.  FCMs and RFEDs hold customer funds in trust.  If a FCM or RFED goes out of business the collateral damage to the firm’s customers and to the confidence of market participants is far worse than with your average business, which is why the standards need to be much higher.  In short, any FCM or RFED that holds customer funds in trust needs to accept the costs that come along with that trust.

FXCM appreciates the opportunity to offer these comments to the Commission on the November 14th Proposal.
 
Sincerely,
 
Drew Niv
Chief Executive Officer
Forex Capital Markets LLC
55 Water Street, 50th floor
New York, NY 10041
 
 

About FXCM Inc.

 
FXCM Inc. (NYSE: FXCM) is a global online provider of foreign exchange (forex) trading and related services to retail and institutional customers world-wide.
 
At the heart of FXCM's client offering is No Dealing Desk forex trading. Clients benefit from FXCM's large network of forex liquidity providers enabling FXCM to offer competitive spreads on major currency pairs. Clients have the advantage of mobile trading, one-click order execution and trading from real-time charts. FXCM's U.K. subsidiary, Forex Capital Markets Limited, also offers CFD products with no re-quote trading and allows clients to trade oil, gold, silver and stock indices along with forex on one platform. In addition, FXCM offers educational courses on forex trading and provides free news and market research through DailyFX.com.
TAGS: FXCM  CFTC  NFA  GFT  Forex Club  Advanced Markets  forex trading  RFED  FCM  PFG Best  MF Global  forex customer protection 

More news about FXCM

Broker Country Regulation Platform Min Deposit Review
Cyprus, UK, Mauritius CySec, FCA, IFSC MT4, MT5, Web $10 Review Website
Cyprus, Australia CySec, ASIC MT4, Web,
Mobile app
$100 Review Website
Australia ASIC MT4, MT5,
IRESSTrader
$100 Review Website
UK, Cyprus, Australia FCA, CySec, ASIC MT4, MT5 $5 Review Website
UK, Australia FCA, ASIC MT4, Trading
Station,
NinjaTrader
$50 Review Website
UK, Cyprus, UAE, South Africa FCA, CySEC, DFSA, FSB MT4, MT5, FxPro
Markets,
cTrader
$100 Review Website
Cyprus CySEC MT4, MT5, Web $1 Review Website
Belize IFSC MT4, MT5 $100 Review Website
Cyprus, UK, South Africa, UAE CySec, FCA, FSCA, DFSA MT4, MT5, Web $5 Review Website
Cyprus, UK CySEC, FCA MT4, MT5 $1 Review Website
Australia ASIC MT4, MT5 $100 Review Website
UK FCA MT4, Web, MT4
for Mac
$100 Review Website

More Forex Brokers News

FXTM appoints Han Tan as a Market Analyst for Southeast Asia region

Apr 19 2019 13:28:36

  Global award-winning forex broker FXTM has just announced the appointment of Tan Chung Han (Han Tan) as a Market Analyst. Read more

FXTM gets a license from Mauritius’ FSC

Mar 28 2019 09:59:36

  Award-winning forex brokerage  FXTM (ForexTime) continues its ongoing global expansion. The broker announced it has acquired a license from the Financial Services Commission (FSC) of the Republic of Mauritius previous week. Read more

Fortrade is the first broker to get an ASIC license in nearly 2 years

Mar 20 2019 15:03:35

  Fortrade acquired a financial services license from the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), which hasn’t been very welcoming of new retail forex broker applicants lately. Read more

FP Markets launches a suite of cutting-edge MT4 tools for traders

Mar 06 2019 14:31:42

  FP Markets, a market-leading Forex and CFD provider, launches MT4 Trader Toolbox, a suite of twelve online trading tools which will take their clients’ trading to the next level. Read more

Major broker IG launched its US website

Jan 31 2019 13:15:37

  Global brokerage IG launched its website intended for US retail clients (www.ig.com/us). Residents of the US (with the exception of those in Arizona or Ohio) can now register on the broker’s website in less than 5 minutes and start trading. Read more

FOREX.com announced important updates to its Web Trading platform

Jan 25 2019 15:13:43

  Major forex brokerage  Forex.com  proudly announced important updates of its in-house Web Trading platform, which will take your trading experience to the next level.   Accessible from all browsers and operating systems, Web Trading was launched in 2017. Read more

HotForex parent gets licensed by UK’s FCA

Jan 21 2019 12:31:59

  Less than a month after HotForex acquired license to operate in the UAE, the trading services provider gets an authorization by the Financial Conduct Authority of the UK. The UK subsidiary of the HF Markets Group, HF Markets (UK) Ltd. Read more

Rakuten Securities offers HK$700 prepaid cards as a welcome gift

Jan 18 2019 10:26:57

  Hong Kong forex broker Rakuten Securities offers up to HK$700 Spending Limit Prepaid Card as a welcome gift to new account registrants. Here are all the details you need to know about the company’s promotional offer, which is valid from now until the end of March 2019. Read more

XM applies for a forex dealer license in the US

Jan 11 2019 13:39:14

  The US subsidiary of major forex brokerage XM has applied for a membership with the National Futures Association (NFA). This became clear from a filing by the broker’s US entity Trading.com Markets Inc. (previously Trading Point US Inc.) with the NFA dated January 3, 2019. Read more

HotForex acquired DFSA license, commences operations in the UAE

Jan 08 2019 10:45:37

  HotForex is now licensed by the Dubai Financial Services Authority (DFSA) and announced it commences operations in the United Arab Emirates (UAE). The Dubai arm of the HF Markets Group, HF Markets (DIFC) Ltd., acquired the DFSA license in December last year. Read more

de | cn | ru