Market News

European Council Reaches Agreement Regarding MiFID II

After nine months of grueling negotiations, the European Council has finally achieved a breakthrough in discussions regarding the revision of the Markets in Financial Instruments Directive (MiFID). An agreement has been reached among the members of the Council, and a spokesperson for the Irish EU presidency stated before the Financial Times that the deal will be officially signed this week, bringing the long-awaited MiFID II a step closer to completion.
 
MiFID has been the ruling legislation for financial transactions in the European Union for several years now. It was initially designed to bring about a harmonized regulation for investment services across the European Economic Area (EEA), and introduce better consumer protection in investment services. Its most prominent aspects included a demand for more transparency, both before and after a trade is executed, client categorization as "eligible counterparties", professional clients or retail clients (who receive highest protection protection), and a requirement for the amount of information a company collects from its client before accepting an order. The Directive also introduced the so-called MiFID passport, which allows companies falling under its jurisdiction to be authorized and regulated by the country where they have a registered office, even when dealing with clients from other EU member states. 
 
MiFID II will revise and complement the first version, addressing issues such as banks' trading activities, dark pools, and high-frequency trading (HFT), among others. But the most significant change will be the introduction of a new category, an Organized Trading Facility (OTF), which will encompass all asset classes, including Forex, bonds, equities, etc. It will also capture all currently unregulated trading venues, including "broker-crossing networks" - networks of brokers matching clients' orders with each other outside organized trading venues, which are hidden from the market There is a special provision planned for equities OTFs – two years after application, they will be subject to an evaluation to determine whether they have been harmful to the market in any way. 
 
Some of the other proposals made by the Council include a special clause that will allow brokerages more discretion regarding trade execution, and a requirement for clearing houses to clear financial instruments “on a non-discriminatory and transparent basis regardless of the trading venue on which a transaction is executed”. Matched principal transactions also have not been overlooked. These types of transactions allow traders to trade on market exchanges and participate in over-the-counter (OTC) transactions. If the proposed version of MiFID II is accepted, matched principal trading will only be acceptable for bonds and non-standardized (off-exchange) derivatives, to the exclusion of equities.
 
Severe restrictions are planned for HFT and the so-called “dark pools” - trading venues off the lit markets. According to the proposals, anyone using algorithmic trading will be forced to submit their algorithms and strategies to regulators, and provide proper risk control to prevent market disruptions (as stated, in fact, by the German HFT Act passed earlier this year). As for dark pools, the Council is pushing for a limit of no more than 4% off-the-market trading per venue, and 8% for the entire EU region as a whole.
 
 

MiFID II impact on the market

 
Probably the greatest impact that MiFID II could have on foreign exchange is that, as we mentioned, Forex will fall under the category of OTF and will benefit from the greater transparency and investor protection that is paramount to the Directive. Unfortunately for brokers, increased transparency also means increased costs for reporting. Opinions have also been expressed that the limitations on dark pools and HFT could seriously disrupt brokers' current workflow.
 
Equity trading will probably be most affected by MiFID II in its current state. European stock exchanges have argued that including equities in the OTF category would reduce investor protection, allowing preferential treatment to certain clients. It is also possible that small and medium enterprises will have trouble raising capital in the EU.
 
Of course, it has to be noted that, even after the proposal is officially signed by the European Council this week, it will be some time before it can become part of standard EU legislature. A “trialogue” between the Council, European Commission and European Parliament will most likely result in further amendments to MiFID II. The process is expected to be long and difficult, as the three sides of the trialogue have had many points of discord in discussions so far. For example, the European Parliament is against the inclusion of equities among OTFs, while the Commission was in fact the first to propose the new category back in October 2011. Though the MiFID II is not likely to become a law until next year the earliest (or maybe even as late as 2015), the new proposal is clearly a step in the right direction. 
 
In any case, changes to legislature are at this point inevitable. The US has already led the way with the signing of the Dodd-Frank act and the recent introduction of Swap Execution Facility (SEF), a platform for regulated swap trading (swap being the exchange of one asset or liability for a similar asset or liability for the purpose of shifting risk, as per official definition). I mean, it's not for nothing OTF's have now acquired the nickname “European SEF”. The best action for Europe now seems to be to try and catch up to the US, bringing its financial markets under strict control.   
 
 
TAGS: european council  mifid  mifid ii  agreement  mifid ii agreement 

More Forex Market News

FXPA: A new association addresing forex market regulation

Sep 26 2014 13:17:06

FXPA’s aim is to provide strong advocacy for the FX industry, engaging key financial regulators and policymakers.   Today marks the launch of the Foreign Exchange Professionals Association (FXPA), a new trade body uniquely comprised of a cross-section of FX industry participants. Read more

Forex Scam: France’s financial regulator AMF warns about 166 unregulated brokers

Sep 24 2014 16:23:19

French financial regulator AMF has warned the investors against 166 unregulated forex and binary option brokers, operating in the country without proper authorization. Read more

Myfxbook advertises forex contest sponsored by the controversial ForexBrokerInc

Sep 15 2014 12:35:41

Myfxbook, the reputable social trading platform, is running a contest with a controversial and unregulated forex broker, ForexBrokerInc, against which the Malta Financial Service Authority has warned the public. Read more

Forex Scam: ASIC cautions against First Forex, FiFx, and FiFx Global

Sep 15 2014 09:00:02

The Australian regulator informs the public that First Forex, FiFx and FiFx Global (fifx.com) falsely claim that their services are under the regulation of ASIC (Regulation No. 290600). Read more

Forex Scam: FCA warns against LEM Spreads

Sep 12 2014 12:48:07

The UK regulator has found another company that is better to be avoided. The company called LEM Spreads offers its highly suspicious service at lem-spreads.net and lemspreads.com. Read more

Forex Scam: FCA issued a warning against PlusFN

Sep 11 2014 12:53:17

The UK regulator warns against an unregulated entity using the names PlusFN Ltd +FN, and Equity Sky Capital Marketing Limited (plusfn.com). Read more

US regulator fines Zulutrade $150k for accepting accounts from Iran, Sudan, and Syria

Sep 10 2014 10:51:22

Zulutrade, one of the two largest social trading platforms, has settled a case with the US Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) for accepting clients from countries that are sanctioned financially by the US. Read more

ASIC rescinds Global Derivative Services Ltd license

Sep 09 2014 09:16:29

The Australian regulator concluded that Global Derivative Services Pty Ltd has failed to comply with a number of its AFS license obligations. As a result the company’s Australian financial services (AFS) license is cancelled. Read more

Forex Scam: FCA warns against BAM Forex a clone of BAM Capital Ltd

Sep 08 2014 10:23:21

The UK regulator issues a warning against BAM Forex (bamcapitalltd.co and bamforex.co) which is using the credentials of BAM Capital Ltd (bam-capital.co.uk) to mislead people it is a regulated and safe company.   Another day, another fraud scheme revealed by a regulator. Read more

Forex Scam: Ontario Securities Commission warns against Forex Barter Inc.

Sep 04 2014 12:42:41

One of the Canadian regulators, those of the province of Ontario, is warning that Forex Barter Inc. is not authorized to offer financial services in its jurisdiction.   So, we decided to take a look into Forex Barter's matters since a regulator warning is always to be taken serious. Read more